I have been sitting on this review for over a week. I haven’t been entirely sure what to say. Finales are always the hardest things to review: by this point either you are a Scott Pilgrim  reader or  you are not. Often times with these things you are speaking to the converted.

It is remarkably hard to say good-bye to Scott Pilgrim, for it is the defining pop-culture experience of my early twenties. Which is a remarkably pretentious thing to write, now that I have typed it out. However, that doesn’t make it any less true. What’s most impressive about the overall Scott Pilgrim experience is how O’Malley so successfully synthesized the pop-culture detritus (video games, shonen manga, superheroes) running around in the brains of males in their 20s and 30s into a such a successful relationship drama and coming of age story. The final volume puts an very good cap on all of this. Things end as they should and as you would expect.

Read the rest of this entry »